(reprinted from the September 2007 Potrero Boosters newsletter)
Since December, dozens of Potrero Hill residents (between 30 and 70 neighbors at every meeting so far) have been working to come up with a stronger, more responsive, and more thorough community-based planning process. These workshops were convened by the Boosters, the Dogpatch Neighborhood Association, the Potrero Hill Association of Merchants and Businesses, and Save Potrero as a way to improve the long-term rezoning process that has taken the City’s Planning Department most of this decade to develop. We will be publishing our community land use recommendations in late October.
At Tuesday’s Boosters meeting (September 25), we be will continuing our conversation from the last meeting on September 8, where we discussed strategies to get meaningful contributions to public benefits into our neighborhood planning.
Here’s some of what we’ve accomplished at Plan Potrero Hill in these past months:
• We’ve built a growing consensus around a new land use map, showing the centers of our new neighborhoods, and locations for open space.
• We’ve contained bioscience uses and large offices in one large portion of the Central Waterfront.
• We’ve combined the Showplace Square and Central Waterfront neighborhoods, and added the Port, Mission Bay, UCSF, and public housing land to our planning area.
• We’ve added the Department of Public Health’s ENCHIA standards to our public benefits discussion.
• We’ve demanded that transit improvements have to be part of new developments in our neighborhoods.
• We helped develop one of the best Planning Dept. proposals in years for getting sites for affordable housing.
• We’ve revived discussion about legalizing in-law units.
• We’ve influenced the Planning Department staff consensus, changing their proposed zoning map and getting us closer than we have ever been to good planning for our new neighborhoods.
None of these things were true in December 2006.
The big remaining problem, as it was in December 2006, is creating a real public benefits program to go along with the zoning. It’s hung us up for most of the summer, just like it’s hung up the Planning Department.
In December 2006, the proposed Potrero Hill area plan needed strong analysis of neighborhood needs, a clear strategy for funding necessary improvements, and official ‘nexus’ studies connecting the two. In September 2007, those things are still needed, especially the ‘nexus’ studies. The Planning Department tells us they will have those studies late this year.
But what are our neighborhood’s priorities, once we have those studies? (We will make some progress on this question at Tuesday night’s Boosters meeting.) And, just as important, how does the Planning Department handle building projects in the ‘pipeline’ – those who have current applications and are pushing for approval now, before the plans are adopted?
The city’s Planning Commission’s made one ill-considered attempt at a decision on that second question with a vote on August 30, where they decided to exempt all pipeline projects from making any significant contributions to public improvements if they are approved in the next few months. That was a spectacularly stupid vote (some commissioners were falling asleep as they were voting!), with potentially huge implications. At this point, many years into a long planning process, there are dozens and dozens of projects, with thousands of housing units, in the Showplace Square/Central Waterfront ‘pipeline.’ Any decision on those pipeline projects could affect more than half of the entire future development of our new neighborhoods; so exempting those projects from contributing to public benefits could destroy our planning before it’s even completed.
Fortunately for us, we continue to have a Board of Supervisors that is willing to protect our neighborhoods during this critical final stretch of the community planning process. This past Tuesday, Supervisor Tom Ammiano introduced a strong set of interim controls designed to limit approvals of ‘pipeline’ projects in the Eastern Neighborhoods while plans for those neighborhoods are being completed. At the moment, interim controls are our best hope to ensure that everyone contributes their fair share to our future neighborhoods, and Potrero Hill has to show up to support the Board when the time comes to consider the controls in October.
For more background and info, join us on Tuesday! NOW MORE THAN EVER, your input is critical in making this neighborhood, your neighborhood.
Tags:
Affordable Housing,
Community Planning Meeting Minutes,
Zoning